Ping ([info]zestyping) wrote,
@ 2006-11-21 06:14:00
Previous Entry  Add to memories!  Tell a Friend!  Next Entry
Zhongdian.
(This post describes Sunday, November 19.)

Zhongdian is also known as Di Qing or Xianggelila — Shangri-La, about 200 km away from the Tibetan border by road. My dad and i are at about 3200m above sea level, on our way back to Zhongdian after a day touring the countryside, driving among little villages nestled between mountains covered with dense evergreen forests. Or rather, we're not the ones driving; our lives are in the expert hands of an employee of the education department, who is managing to hit 100 km/h on these winding paved roads while (by some miracle) narrowly avoiding running into other cars, the people walking down the middle of the road, and the occasional wandering yak. Out the window i can see the terraced fields of highland wheat.





My parents donated money to build three schools here, each one named after one of my grandparents (with the exception of my paternal grandfather, who died before i ever got to know him). The first one we visited this morning was the largest, an elementary school for Grades 1 to 6 with about a hundred students. Getting there required a 45-minute ride along a wiggly gravel road full of enormous potholes and cracks — the kind of bumpy ride on which you risk clunking your head against the car window if you're not paying attention. By the time we arrived, the students were all waiting for us, lined up in brilliant costumes (the boys in white and the girls in pink) along the side of the road. When we got out of the car, they all began clapping in rhythm and loudly chanting words of welcome. One of the older girls came forward to place a white silk streamer over my father's neck — their customary gesture of greeting — and another one did the same for me. We were led past them into the school's courtyard, which was set up with tables at the front.

The whole affair was eerily royal. We sat down at the tables, with bowls of fruit and an empty courtyard before us. They offered us tea. The children lined up in neat rows. They had set up a PA system, and handed my dad a microphone; he said a few words about how happy he was to be here to see the school. He passed me the microphone and suggested i say something, so i explained that this was my first visit to China and that i was glad my parents had caused this school to be built. My dad translated this for me, and everyone applauded. Then they turned on music and the children began dancing for us. It felt to me like i was playing the role of the rich foreigner whose poor subjects had to perform to curry my favour. Sitting there got to be a bit much for me, so i asked whether i could dance with them. I have no idea whether i was breaking some sort of protocol, but i figured the children wouldn't mind, and i wanted to lessen the distance between me and them. I hoped it wouldn't hurt. No one seemed offended, anyway; one of the teachers seemed happy enough to show me how to follow the steps, and i did catch a few of the kids smiling back at me when i made eye contact.

We had brought lots of pencilcases and red envelopes, which we handed out, one of each to each child. Each red envelope contained ¥10, which would be about two weeks of income for one of these families. Then we got up to check out the classrooms, and the children rushed to take their places at the desks so that we could see them there when we looked in. We said a few things to them, talked to the teachers about the school, and then went on our way, with everyone clapping and waving us off.



The routine was similar at all the other schools we visited. (I didn't dance at the others.) In addition to fruit and tea, they offered us hard liquor, cigarettes, sunflower seeds, yak milk, heaping bowls of highland wheat flour, dry corn pancakes, and chicken soup. (That yellow stuff in the bowls is the yak milk; the silver bowl contains the alcohol; and the brown shiny thing behind the table is the lid of a bowl containing highland wheat flour. The yak milk tasted like vaguely salty soup, and the pancakes were crumbly and fairly tasteless.)



The parents danced for us too — a line of men and a line of women dancing opposite each other and singing to each other. I didn't really know what to make of it — the whole village putting on this show just for us — but it did make sense from their point of view, i guess. If you get a visit from someone who can donate 500 times your annual income to build a school that could mean a better life for your kids, i suppose you'd want to do just about anything to make them happy.

And the kids were happy. I don't know what their parents had told them — whether they were nervous about performing well for us, or if they thought of us as alien beings or just strange-looking friends wearing strange-looking clothes — but they really did seem happy. Some of the things i've been thinking about the past few days bubbled to the surface as i looked over their smiling faces. What effect would One Laptop Per Child have here? Would it really help these children? What about the way they grow food here — would these open fields of wheat and chickens and yaks be one day replaced by overfertilized soil and a confined animal feeding operation?

This whole trip has been a lesson in disparity. Not just the incredible disparity between the rich and poor — the little makeshift houses in which these children lived, compared to the astonishingly fancy hotel where we stayed in the town of Zhongdian, which the government had subsidized in order to attract tourists — but also a surprising disparity in perceptions of value. The last elementary school we visited had mobile phone coverage, but didn't have running water in the bathrooms (i asked my dad to insist that the teachers run a hose from the nearby creek and train the kids to wash their hands after going to the bathroom). The place where we ate lunch didn't have proper interior walls or insulation against the cold, but they had a pretty big TV.

And how much of this disparity was i projecting upon them? Did the villagers really feel like they were supplicating themselves to us, or was that just in my head? They probably didn't want pity, but i couldn't help feeling some of it. If this was the only life they knew, it would all be normal to them. How dare we change their way of life? How dare we not change their way of life? Prime Directive be damned, if they lack the resources to provide health care for their children...



When we got back to town, we also visited a much larger high school. It had over a thousand students; the principal took me and my dad inside to talk to the students of the graduating class. The moment i set foot in the classroom, the students burst into applause, and then one of the students stood up and read a carefully prepared statement in English welcoming me to the school. I was still not used to the attention, but i did my best to be encouraging. I asked them what their favourite subject was. "English!" they all chorused. They could understand some of what i said in English, and took turns asking me questions in Chinese (which my dad translated) or in broken English sentences. One of them asked me for advice on how to do well at the university entrance exam; one asked me why i liked math; but mostly they wanted to know how to learn better English. I suggested getting lots of practice, and left them my e-mail address.

It seemed the most important thing to these kids was to Westernize as quickly as possible. I don't know exactly what to make of that, either.

Here's one more picture — this on the wall in the high school — for your closing Moment of Zen.



(Post a new comment)


[info]farwing
2006-11-21 02:40 pm UTC (link)
Wow. Thank you for sharing your trip.

(Reply to this)


[info]one_in_progress
2006-11-21 03:17 pm UTC (link)
I'm also really appreciating your stories - thanks!! I can imagine it might all seem a little surreal.

(Reply to this)


[info]paisleychick
2006-11-21 04:29 pm UTC (link)
sounds like you're having a really interesting and trying time. Seems like your parents are doing great work although I understand the bit about your being uncomfortable with people putting on a show for you and your father. Hope you have a good time with the rest of your trip!

(Reply to this)


[info]threadwalker
2006-11-21 06:29 pm UTC (link)
Amazing things.

One lesson I've gotten from years of living with my mother is that you have to be very careful about the impulse to "help". Obvious, yes, but in her case there's a lot of depth to it. She's an anthropologist who has worked most of her career in public health. Unlike modernisation and tech and culture "improvements", better health care is much easier to argue. But even there, you have to be very careful about the culture. You would be surprised at the potential obsticals to a hose. The trick is to find a culturally acceptable way to insert handwashing into a a school, and it might take several months to figure that out.

As for the rest, you'd probably need to live years in a place with a lot of respect for it before you start suggesting improvements. Some "improvements" come at too great a sacrifice to culture (TV?). Others will be used (or not used at all) for reasons that would never occur to an outsiders.

Example- a US aid group wanted to build a community center in the hills in Guatemala so that the spread out little houses and villages would have a place to meet collectively to discuss health, edcation, etc. The people agreed that they needed meetings, but were upset at the money being spent on a building. Some bright person asked them what they would do. "Give us instruments" they said. No one will want to come to an empty American building, but if we have music, people will come from all over to dance, and stay to talk. And they did.

Integrating better healthcare is tricky. Also, there are plenty of examples where westerners came in and mucked things up by assuming they knew best. In the Andes, people drank a traditional drink made of chalk. Americans made an ad campain against "drinking mud" and a little while later, people started suffering from calcium deficiancy. So they had to reverse it a generation later with "drink you cultural hertitage" ads. *sigh*

I understand the impulse to leap to action, but so important to get a good sense of the existing thing first. How old is the culture you're looking at? I am sure they could not tell you a fraction of the actual benifits of every tiny, insignificant-seeming custom.

(Reply to this) (Thread)


[info]flipzagging
2006-11-21 10:18 pm UTC (link)
That's really interesting.

I just finished a book called Leaving Microsoft to Change the World -- an ex-Microsoftie sales guy gets inspired to found libraries all over the world.

Everywhere, it seems, the children and teachers clamor for English books. As much as we may be concerned about cultural imperialism, it's hard to argue with their sincere demand.

Also, the charity (Room to Read) won't found a library unless there's tangible buy-in from the locals -- like, the parents have agreed to cart bricks up the hill or something. In the book that's presented as evidence of partner commitment, but I guess it also ensures they don't build libraries where they aren't wanted.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]threadwalker
2006-11-21 11:19 pm UTC (link)
Sounds like they are being better than many such organisations.

(Reply to this) (Parent)


[info]chimerically
2006-11-23 09:04 pm UTC (link)
As much as we may be concerned about cultural imperialism, it's hard to argue with their sincere demand.

It is hard to argue with, especially from a privileged perspective: who are us Westerners* to say "we have these things, but you can't have them because it's ruining your cultural heritage/the environment/etc." But at the same time, Western quality of life isn't sustainable in many ways even for just the percentage of the world's population that's following it now, much less the rising middle classes in other countries. Also, the Western way of life isn't as positive as many who don't follow it may think (since their perceptions are often shaped by movies and television). Anyway, it's a very complicated issue ... hard to know how to react or what to do, other than educate everyone about the issues the best one can.

(* Here I use "Westerners" to mean people in developed, consumption-oriented countries, including the US, Canada, Europe, and a few other places. It's a crappy term but I can't think of anything better. I had one prof. who used "global north" and "global south," but that takes even more explanation.)

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]flipzagging
2006-11-23 10:06 pm UTC (link)
hard to know how to react or what to do, other than educate everyone about the issues the best one can.

I agree, but you know, your prescription isn't culture-neutral either.

The idea that "everyone should be informed" is one of the great legacies of the West. In some cultures, the response is "let's let the elder males study this and tell us what's right".

I'm not trying to tweak you, but I'm just saying, we have the power; morally we are obligated to use it; and that entails making value judgments.

Some judgments should not be made, like "drink Coca Cola", or "your economy should become dependent on free-trading commodity exports". But I feel pretty confident about increasing access to information for everyone.

Room To Read has special programs to sponsor girls through school, which happens to be the #1 way to combat poverty. But that is also a huge disruption for cultures that are traditionally sexist. I still approve.

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]chimerically
2006-11-24 07:09 am UTC (link)
Yep, I know, but it's something I value enough that I'm willing to promote it more widely. There *is* no way to be culturally neutral. :~)

(Reply to this) (Parent)

(Deleted post)

[info]threadwalker
2008-07-16 06:35 am UTC (link)
Meh?

(Reply to this) (Parent)(Thread)


[info]zestyping
2008-07-20 09:47 am UTC (link)
It's spam. It's getting terrible these days.

(Reply to this) (Parent)

(Reply from suspended user)

[info]leech
2006-11-21 07:38 pm UTC (link)
Thanks for writing about this. It was very interesting to read about your experience.

(Reply to this)


[info]boredatheist
2006-11-22 12:27 am UTC (link)
All these stories have been awesome. I'm sending them to my friends.

(Reply to this)


[info]hyper_boy
2006-11-23 06:48 am UTC (link)
reminds me of the time i went to indonesia to visit the motherland. sanitation there was also somewhat sketchy in some areas (waste removal workers were on a strike at the time), with garbage heaps climbing 1-2 stories. after a heavy rain, 2 people were killed by a trashslide in their village.

(Reply to this)


[info]chimerically
2006-11-23 09:05 pm UTC (link)
Fabulous posts -- thanks for writing! It can be a very unsettling experience to be the "privileged" one in situations like the ones you've described ... I look forward to hearing more about it all.

(Reply to this)


Create an Account
Forgot your login?
Login w/ OpenID
English • Español • Deutsch • Русский…